Tuesday, June 17, 2008
Fun Approach To The Most Common Student Loan
Please forward this email to friends, family, and co-workers who have students in high school.
Yahoo, MySpace, Google, DailyMotion, Blip.tv and Howcast
Tuesday, June 3, 2008
Tax Exempt Status For 9 MA Colleges With Billion Dollar Endowments
With these huge fortunes just sitting there earning vast amounts of interest daily, these are colleges which, on a student's appeal for more financial aid, will respond by saying that there are "not enough funds available." When it comes to discussing finances, these colleges have no credibility as their public remarks boggle the mind.
Here's an example:
Boston College justified raising its tuition last year on the basis that their employee health care costs and energy costs were rising. To add insult to the injury of increasing tuition costs, a BC official was quoted in a Boston Globe article: "Excellence is an expensive proposition." Not to be outdone in the elitism department, when the president of BC, Rev. William Leahy, was asked about the school's BILLION dollar endowment, and if it would mean rising tuitions would stop at BC, his response was: "A billion dollars is a great deal of money, but it by no means eliminates all the pressure."
Pressure? The Boston Globe reported that BC was able to outbid for a purchase of real estate near its campus for nearly 100 million dollars "with cash up front." That's how BC defines pressure - having to bid with 100 million dollars in cash up front. I'm probably naive for suggesting this, but maybe their tax exemption is helping to relieve some of that pressure. Do you think?
Derek Bok, former president of Harvard, said in a recent book: "Universities share one characteristic with compulsive gamblers and exiled royalty: there is never enough money to satisfy their desires."
Members of the Massachusetts legislature are now considering eliminating the tax exemption. They're looking to impose a paltry 2.5% tax, half of what private foundations are required to pay. But my guess is that these colleges are not worried. They won't even bother sending their lobbyists to protest the proposed tax. If it happens, the colleges will do what you can already predict: raise tutions and fees.
With good intentions mixed with lots of pandering, Massachusetts politicians will likely enact this tax and parents who send their kids to these schools will pay more.
Now you know why such colleges as these don't care what you think about what they charge. As long as the demand to get into these schools far exceeds the supply of seats, colleges will continue to corner the market on arrogance, or, biting the hands that feed them.
AfterThought: Harvard is attempting to be the exception: students whose parents make less than $60,000 a year get free tuition. But how many exceptionally bright students who meet Harvard's requirements come from homes earning less than $60,000 a year? Not surprisingly Harvard doesn't say. Could it be that Harvard's own press releases want us all to think that it doesn't want any child left behind? My cynicism must be showing....
Sunday, June 1, 2008
More Dishonesty From Colleges: Dropping The SAT Requirement
Baloney. Pure. Extra Virgin.
It's part of the PC mentality that runs amok on colleges campuses everywhere. Two examples are illustrated in today's NY Times: Smith College & Wake Forest.
From Wake Forest University: “By making the SAT and ACT optional, we hope to broaden the applicant pool and increase access at Wake Forest for groups of students who are currently underrepresented (italics added) at selective universities,” Martha Allman, director of admissions at Wake Forest, told the Times.
Did you get the gobbledigook in this statement? "Underrepresented" what? Are they dummies whose test scores don't meet the school's "extraordinary" standards?
Here's the veiled truth in the Times article that gets missed: "Applicants to both schools will have the option to submit their test scores." Read: we colleges want to use these test scores as a tie-breaker with equally competiting students. Plus, if truth be told, we want to make our decisions easier, our jobs easier, not more difficult.
If colleges could be accused of trying to monopolize dishonesty, this is a validating example.
To demonstrate the success of such a press release, this one was issued 2 years ago by Holy Cross College (Worcester, MA), which asked this question: "Why would a student submit standardized test scores if they don't have to?" Their answer: "A student might decide that his or her test score gives a more competitive picture of academic achievements and potential."
Replace the word "student" with the word "college" in the above statement and you have Truth in Advertising. Like most elitist colleges, Holy Cross likes to engage in feel-good Oprah babble to make us all feel warm and fuzzy about what they represent, or more accurately, how they market their image. After all, these colleges are a business whose strategy is to design, package, market, and sell their image. They've attended expensive marketing seminars where they have learned that perception is reality, and reality is what they want parents and students to perceive, not actually what is.
So far roughly 70% of students who apply to colleges that require no standardized test scores submit their SAT and ACT scores anyway. Talk about being competitive.
If you were working in the admissions office, what would you be thinking of those applications that did NOT come with their SAT scores? "Hmmmm...does this student have something to hide?" How's that for reality?
Bottom Line: If these colleges were honest and forthright, they would require that their applicants not submit their standardized test scores. When the first college in the United States makes non-submittal of test scores a requirement in its application process, watch for this TV news headline: "Hell freezes over. Film at eleven."
The dishonesty of "non-SAT" colleges is astounding, proving once again that marketing their image trumps the truth we parents deserve.
Wednesday, May 28, 2008
How To Impress Colleges
Tuesday, April 1, 2008
Student Debt: What Are We Thinking?
Not counting the yearly 6% increases he'll receive from the college, and because his parents are strapped for funds to help him pay, his debt upon graduation - at age 22 - will exceed $140,000.
As a real consequence, imagine the following scenario. Three or four years after graduation, he meets the girl of his dreams, and before long the discussion of marriage comes up. But before they both decide to make the Big Decision, the conversation goes like this, starting with the young man:
"I can't tell you how lucky I am to be with you."
"I feel the same way."
Then she asks: "Before we go any further with talk of marriage, I need to ask you one question."
"What's that, sweetheart?"
"How much college debt do you have?"
"Oh...about $140,000. My payments are about $1,500 a month."
"Really? Well, how are we going to buy a house and raise a family over the next ten years with your debt? Plus, I have about $40,000 of my own."
You can see where this is going. How 'bout nowhere? That is, the couple look at each other in exasperation, and for very practical reasons, maybe she opts outs of the relationship and two good hearts are broken.
I asked my student if he could process what a $140,000 debt means. He confessed that he couldn't. Maybe it's some sort of fictional phenomenon that other people worry about, similar to a tornado disaster we New Englanders only see on TV. We know tornadoes happen in Oklahoma and Texas, but not here.
Very slowly this tornado of debt is heading toward this young high school senior, and he doesn't even see it.
Any thoughts? Please post your comments here.
Sunday, March 30, 2008
How To Get Off A College's Wait-List: A Solution
Here's a solution (I'm not guaranteeing this will work, but some of my students have made it work).
First determine how badly you really want to go to this college. Let's assume you'd crawl on broken glass for a mile to attend. Great!...you've got your enthusiasm engine fired up, which is exactly the energy you need to make things happen. It's enthusiasm that's going to get someone's attention in the admissions office. It's what I like to call the Gentle Sledgehammer Approach.
The next thing you do is write down on one sheet of paper the 2 or 3 reasons why you absolutely must attend your #1 choice (example = Professor Pin Head is THE expert in the field I want to study, and I have to study under him!), but more importantly, give 3 reasons how the college will benefit from you being one of their students.
Then call the admissions office to find out when the admissions people are in. Go to the school unannounced (asking for an appointment on the phone will get you nowhere) and ask the receptionist if you can have a 2-minute meeting with an admissions counselor. You'll be asked, "What's this regarding?" Simply respond, "I've been wait-listed and all I need is 2 minutes to see an admissions counselor."
Chances are very good you'll get your meeting. Once you're in the admissions counselor's office, have your sheet of paper ready and start by thanking the person for their time. Introduce yourself and state that you appreciate having 2 minutes of their time to discuss what you wrote down. Chances are good that you'll get more time because admissions people never see a line of wait-listed students outsides their office.
Be prepared to hear the counselor say that you can simply hand over your sheet of paper, that it will be reviewed later, and that you can leave. Respond that you'd be happy to, but then state your case with enthusiasm, which is what the admissions person wants to see and hear! After all, how many opportunities do you think this admissions person gets to see and hear someone like you? Hardly ever!
After you leave, you will leave behind not only a piece of paper, but a powerful and positive impression of YOU. When the admission committee finalizes their applicants from the wait-list, guess who they're going to think of first?
Good luck to you!
Tuesday, March 25, 2008
The Heartbreak Of Achievement
I see this scenario every year at this time, and my heart aches for these kids, but only because their dream school said, "No." I never really addressed this issue as much as I did today when I sent this note to, well, let's call him Chris.
My Dear Chris,
As much as I try to understand why talented students like you do not get accepted, you must recognize that you were not rejected. There is a HUGE difference. The awful reality is NOT knowing why you were not accepted, and if you called the schools to ask why, they would likely compliment you and add why they agonized immeasurably over your great application.
Your application wasn’t accepted because of factors you could not have known in advance, or more troubling, had no control over, such as…
- they already filled their quota of students from Massachusetts by the time your application was reviewed;
- they wanted more students this year whose parents never went to college;
- they slightly exceeded the amount of males they wanted;
- your interest level in the college wasn’t demonstrable enough; or
- they were looking for more “local” students because their own stats indicate that more money comes from alumni who are closer to their geographical location.
And you’re thinking, “This is just too odd! What’s all this got to do with my great grades and SAT scores? I met all their requirements!” I'll bet my house that you did, except for all the stuff you didn’t even imagine could be factored into why you were denied admission. With colleges that accepted you, you met and most likely exceeded their academic requirements, and you met all of their odd criteria too.
You're living your first college lesson in Irony 101.
So rejection was not the end result for you, and I hope you’re clear on this.
These criteria have nothing to do with your long hard efforts and achievements in these past 4 years, which were well recognized by those colleges that hope you show up in September. If you’re not sure by May 1 where to go, see my blog on how to avoid the pressure of May 1: http://www.precollegeprep.blogspot.com/ (See below.)
This is going to be easy for me to say, but I won’t assume you’ll easily accept the implications. Here it is: you’re talented, good colleges have accepted you, and you can move on with your life. Yeah…I know, thanks but no thanks.
But just in case you’re okay with what I’ve said so far, I found something on the net this morning that I thought you could use http://www.theadmissiongame.com/blog/archives/54
By the way, I’ll always be proud of the fact that I had you as one of my better students, which should signal to you that I have full confidence that the decisions you make and where you go will reflect commendably on who you are.
Paul
Monday, March 24, 2008
Welcome To Our New Service
And your comments and questions are part of how this works. If you never add a word or ask a question, you will see what our clients are asking and saying. It should be fun, but more importantly, we promise this service to be informative and VERY up-to-date.
As a bonus feature, only our clients will be allowed to annouce where their kids have been accepted. It's a time for celebration, and we want our clients to tell the world the good news!
BUT...you won't receive this daily blog unless you put in your email address below in the blue rectangle.
Sunday, March 23, 2008
College Is An Expense, Not An Investment
Marketing to your kids by using such press releases says only one thing about the colleges: to get your student to their campus, they must appeal to their instincts. What happend to appealing to their minds?
By contrast, as if not to engage in such superficial behavior, new freshman students at Brown were greeted with these words from the president: "You are the smartest, the cutest, the savviest, extraordinary -- I could go on and on." The seeds were already planted by the school's president that students were going to enjoy a spoiling self-centeredness in an atmosphere of entitlement.
The arrogance of both these approaches from our colleges and universities - pandering to a child's instincts or fostering a sense of entitlement on super talented students - is what we're all forced to pay for.
Message to the parents: your student is going to do well if s/he has a work ethic, proof of his or her own achievement, and a desire to succeed. With over 4,000 colleges in America (read: choices!) you deserve the right to think for yourself without the college marketing machine giving you the impression that you can't survive without their brand of education.
The kind of education a student receives is ultimately up to the student, not up to the environment in which he has chosen for 4-5 years. Only then does college become an investment of time for the student, but parents still have an expense to cover.
Thursday, March 20, 2008
Announcing Our New Blog
I'd like to get your feedback on whether you think your student ought to have their own blog that I can create just for them. You know...to vent, to observe, and to ask their own questions. After all we consider them adults who just so happen to be younger!
Because a blog is created daily by its participants, I just summarized below the article that Amy sent out regarding perfectionism. We hope that you will post your own comments to what you see below.
So let's get started. Tell us what's on your mind!
